TFR Team Review · Oct 30, 2026
DynaShui Fantasy Football
The Kids Are Not AlrightDynasty12 teams1QB · 2RB · 3WR · 1TE · 2FLEX · 1SFRecord 1-6
The Kids Are Not Alright
9th of 12 by value|1-6
Data drivesdynasties
Team state
REBUILD ON TRACK
Now: REBUILD
2 yrs: RELOAD
Overall roster grade
4.9
About average roster value
Overall grade · 4.9 of 10Everything on the roster added up — players and draft picks at this league's values — and set against the league's average roster. An average roster lands around 5.5; 10 is the richest a roster gets.Roster shape
TOP HEAVY
Best TE 4th
Worst WR 12th
Positional grades
League rank · of 12QBQuarterback · 6th of 126th of 12 in quarterback trade value — what the room is worth to move, weighted toward the men who start. It is not a count of points. And 1 clears 14.1 PPG for 2 starting spots — you cannot fill the lineup here, let alone the bench.The fuller the gem, the higher it ranks — a full gem is 1st in the league.
RBRunning Back · 7th of 127th of 12 in running back trade value — what the room is worth to move, weighted toward the men who start. It is not a count of points. 3 clear 9 PPG for 3 starting spots, so there is nothing startable behind the lineup. De'Von Achane is part of that value and out for the season — tradeable, but not scoring for you this year.The fuller the gem, the higher it ranks — a full gem is 1st in the league.
WRWide Receiver · 12th of 1212th of 12 in receiver trade value — what the room is worth to move, weighted toward the men who start. It is not a count of points. And 2 clear 9 PPG for 3 starting spots — you cannot fill the lineup here, let alone the bench.The fuller the gem, the higher it ranks — a full gem is 1st in the league.
TETight End · 4th of 124th of 12 in tight end trade value — what the room is worth to move, weighted toward the men who start. It is not a count of points. That is value, not depth: 2 clear 6 PPG for 2 starting spots, so the rank is the men who start rather than anything behind them.The fuller the gem, the higher it ranks — a full gem is 1st in the league.
FLEXFlex · 9th of 129th of 12 in the trade value left over once your dedicated slots are filled — the pool your 3 flex spots draw from. Neither of your 2 bench flex bodies clears the bar.The fuller the gem, the higher it ranks — a full gem is 1st in the league.
DEPTHDepth · 10th of 1210th of 12 in the trade value of everyone past your starters and flex — the bench you would trade from, not the bench you would start. Your lineup itself ranks 12th of 12 in weekly points.The fuller the gem, the higher it ranks — a full gem is 1st in the league.
Best position
TE 4th
Top third of 12
4th of 12 in tight end trade value — what the room is worth to move, weighted toward the men who start. It is not a count of points. That is value, not depth: 2 clear 6 PPG for 2 starting spots, so the rank is the men who start rather than anything behind them.Biggest gap
WR 12th
Last in the league
12th of 12 in receiver trade value — what the room is worth to move, weighted toward the men who start. It is not a count of points. And 2 clear 9 PPG for 3 starting spots — you cannot fill the lineup here, let alone the bench.Production share
6.5%
vs league avg 8.3%
Value share
7.9%
vs league avg 8.3%
Draft capital
4 1sts · 4 2nds
2 year outlook
REBUILD→RELOAD
Roster workspace
10 starters · 1QB · 2RB · 3WR · 1TE · 2FLEX · 1SFProjected pointsFilled with the best available player at each slot on expected points per game.110.9Starting lineup
SlotPlayerRankPPG
QB
Drake MayeNE · 24QB324.2
Drake MayeNE · 24QB324.2RB
RJ HarveyDEN · 25RB2910.0
RJ HarveyDEN · 25RB2910.0RB
J.K. DobbinsDEN · 27RB449.7
J.K. DobbinsDEN · 27RB449.7WR
Matthew GoldenGB · 23WR1811.8
Matthew GoldenGB · 23WR1811.8WR
Josh DownsIND · 25WR379.8
Josh DownsIND · 25WR379.8WR
Tre' HarrisLAC · 24WR696.7
Tre' HarrisLAC · 24WR696.7TE
Tyler WarrenIND · 24TE412.3
Tyler WarrenIND · 24TE412.3FLEX
TreVeyon HendersonNE · 24RB259.3
TreVeyon HendersonNE · 24RB259.3FLEX
Mason TaylorNYJ · 22TE346.6
Mason TaylorNYJ · 22TE346.6SF
Tua TagovailoaATL · 28QB3810.3
Tua TagovailoaATL · 28QB3810.3Projected points · 10 startersFilled with the best available player at each slot on expected points per game.110.9
Roster
Quarterbacks
4Drake MayeNE · 24QB3HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10No rush to sell, but I do think he is a red flag… not much more upside besides if he can consistently print 20 ppg seasons, versus major downside and not much insulation IMO.Tua TagovailoaATL · 28QB38HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.
Jalen MilroeSEA · 23QB43—
Joe MiltonPHI · 26QB50—Running backs
7
De'Von AchaneIRMIA · 25RB9BUYTFR board · BUY 5/10Put out some feelers based on market price…. Seen wild deals acceptedTreVeyon HendersonNE · 24RB25SELLTFR board · SELL 8/10Price dropping… explosive, but also Rhamondre under contract for 3 years…RJ HarveyDEN · 25RB29HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.
Jonathon BrooksIRCAR · 23RB35SELLTFR board · SELL 5/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.J.K. DobbinsDEN · 27RB44HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.
Keaton MitchellLAC · 24RB56—
Samaje PerineCIN · 31RB90—Wide receivers
11Matthew GoldenGB · 23WR18SELLTFR board · SELL 7/10Start shopping for top 60 prices… bought near 100thJosh DownsIND · 25WR37BUYTFR board · BUY 4/10Interesting w/ chiefs news
Adonai MitchellNYJ · 24WR68HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10WR2 on JetsTre' HarrisLAC · 24WR69SELLTFR board · SELL 10/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.
Ted Hurst IIITB · 22WR70HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.
Jaylin NoelIRHOU · 24WR72HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.
Cyrus AllenKC · 23WR83HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.
Chris Brazzell IIIRCAR · 23WR86HOLDTFR board · HOLD 5/10On the Buy / Hold / Sell board without a written note.
DeMario DouglasNE · 25WR106—
Barion BrownNO · 22WR108—
Jahan DotsonATL · 26WR118BUYTFR board · BUY 3/10He's not good, but once they get a QB in, I expect this to potentially be Vele 2.0Tight ends
3Tyler WarrenIND · 24TE4BUYTFR board · BUY 5/10Stud
Kenyon SadiqNYJ · 21TE6BUYTFR board · BUY 5/10Bullish long term, reload/rebuild assetMason TaylorNYJ · 22TE34—The TFR take
The written take is on its way — the Roadmap below is the full read on this roster in the meantime.
The Roadmap
Your plan
REBUILDWhy rebuildStarting lineup produces 12th of 12 — not enough to win now.Roster value ranks 9th of 12, and climbs once every player is aged two seasons forward.Your core is younger than the league median, so time is on your side.This reads your playoff odds — your record, your lineup and the schedule left — as well as your roster, and leans on them more as the season goes on. Four things decide this split: how many points your starting lineup scores today, how much trade value you hold, what that value looks like once every player is two years older, and how your core's age compares to the rest of the league. Producing now pushes you toward CONTEND, holding value that hasn't reached your lineup yet pushes you toward RELOAD, and being young without the production pushes you toward REBUILD. A close split means the roster genuinely hasn't picked a side.
The Kids Are Not Alright
15%
84%
CONTEND 1%RELOAD 15%REBUILD 84%
Lineup productionYour best legal starting lineup scores 110.9 points a week, 12th of 12 in the league. This is the half of the plan that wins games this season.
12thof 12
12thof 12
Team valueEverything on the roster — players and draft picks at this league's values — ranks 9th of 12. This is the half of the plan that wins the next three years.
9thof 12
9thof 12
Value × productionLeft to right is how much dynasty value you hold against an average team; bottom to top is how many points your best starting lineup scores. Every logo is a team in your league. Top right means both are working; bottom right means the assets are there but not in your lineup yet; top left means you are winning above your talent; bottom left means neither is working. The shaded band through the middle is within 8% of average either way — a team inside it reads as average on that axis.
Weekly production →
fragile contenderdominantrebuildfuture contenderLeague avgDduesybag9.5% of the league's value · 9.0% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%TTet Chiggy Wit It9.3% of the league's value · 8.8% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%Bbenbruck8.8% of the league's value · 7.5% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%Aanunno168.7% of the league's value · 9.5% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%VVenezia FC8.6% of the league's value · 7.8% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%Jjoshweinstock8.3% of the league's value · 8.3% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%KKirko Chain Smokers8.1% of the league's value · 8.9% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%TThe Love Train7.9% of the league's value · 8.3% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%BBootyMuncherNA7.7% of the league's value · 9.1% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%FFree Mason7.7% of the league's value · 7.7% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%KKGreezy127.5% of the league's value · 8.5% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%TYouThe Kids Are Not Alright7.9% of the league's value · 6.5% of its productionAn even split is 8.3%
Dynasty value →UNDERPERFORMINGYou hold −6% the trade value of an average team and score −22% its weekly points. The assets are league-average but the lineup is not — this is a deployment and roster-construction problem before it is a talent problem.
Competitive windowNot open yet — more than two seasons outRead off the roster now (rebuild) and the same roster with everyone two seasons older (reload).
REBUILD ON TRACKREBUILD ON TRACKRight now this roster reads REBUILD — that's the same verdict as its game plan, blending what the starting lineup scores, how much value it holds and how old the core is. In two years, with every player aged forward, roster value lands in the middle third of the league.
TOP HEAVYTOP HEAVYNo starting spot cracks the top 3 of 12, and depth ranks 10th of 12 — nothing behind the starters.
UNDERPERFORMINGUNDERPERFORMINGYou hold −6% the trade value of an average team and score −22% its weekly points. The assets are league-average but the lineup is not — this is a deployment and roster-construction problem before it is a talent problem.
The game plan
Your moves, most important first
WRSell
Matthew Golden
Get a startable WR back
Shop Matthew Golden before his value drops — and get a startable receiver in return, the room has none to spare.
WRBuy
Rome Odunze
WR help · joshweinstock
Buy Rome Odunze from joshweinstock.Trade talks
joshweinstock
Best fit for a deal
Open trade talks with joshweinstock.
QBShop
Drake Maye
Young starter + a 1st
Take calls on Drake Maye — price him at a young starter plus a first.
Top move
Trade down at TE to fix WRYour tight end room is 57% above league average, 4th of 12, while WR is 57% below league average, 12th of 12. But you start 2 tight ends a week once flex slots are filled and only 2 of yours clear 6 PPG, so you cannot simply send one out. Move your most expensive tight end and insist on a startable tight end coming back alongside the receiver — the value gap between the two is what pays for the upgrade. joshweinstock is the roster shaped to take it.
Get a startable tight end back in the same deal — this room has no spare body.
Season odds
We rebuild your league's real schedule, project each team's weekly score from its best legal starting lineup, then play the rest of the season out a few thousand times with realistic week-to-week swing. These are the share of those seasons where you make the bracket and where you win it. Games already played are kept as results, so the numbers sharpen as the season goes.12-team league0%PlayoffsYou make the bracket in 0% of the simulated seasons.
0%TitleYou win it in 0% of them. In a 12-team league an average roster wins about 8%.
2.8Proj. winsYour average record across every simulated season, over 14 regular-season games.
12thProj. seedRanked by average finish across every simulated season, you come out 12th — that, not the win total, sets the seed. You average 2.8 wins over 14 games; the league average is exactly 7.0.
Positional balance
Your roster value vs. league averageEverything you own in each group, added up and set against what an average team in this 12-team league carries there. Right of the line means you hold more than you can start, so that is where a trade should come from. Left of the line is where incoming value should land. FLEX is the best of what is left after your starters; DEPTH is everything behind that.Biggest need
WR−57%
Add up everything you own at WR and it is worth +57% less than an average team here carries — 12th of 12. You start 3 receivers a week, and you are filling those spots below league standard. This is where incoming value should land.Best strength
TE+57%
Add up everything you own at TE and it is worth +57% more than what an average team here carries — 4th of 12. You start 2 tight ends a week once flex slots are filled and 2 of yours clear 6 PPG, so none of it is spare — this is quality to trade down from, not depth to ship out.← Deficit · buy hereLeague averageSurplus · trade from here →
-100%0%+100%
QB
Quarterback · −5% · 6th of 12Add up everything you own at QB and it comes to about what an average team in this league carries there. Nothing to trade from, nothing to fix.
−5%6thRB
Running Back · −32% · 7th of 12Add up everything you own at RB and it is worth +32% less than an average team here carries — 7th of 12. You start 3 running backs a week once flex slots are filled, and you are filling those spots below league standard. This is where incoming value should land.
−32%7thWR
Wide Receiver · −57% · 12th of 12Add up everything you own at WR and it is worth +57% less than an average team here carries — 12th of 12. You start 3 receivers a week, and you are filling those spots below league standard. This is where incoming value should land.
−57%12thTE
Tight End · +57% · 4th of 12Add up everything you own at TE and it is worth +57% more than what an average team here carries — 4th of 12. You start 2 tight ends a week once flex slots are filled and 2 of yours clear 6 PPG, so none of it is spare — this is quality to trade down from, not depth to ship out.
+57%4thFLEX
Flex · −24% · 9th of 129th of 12 in the trade value left over once your dedicated slots are filled — the pool your 3 flex spots draw from. Neither of your 2 bench flex bodies clears the bar.
−24%9thDEPTH
Depth · −42% · 10th of 1210th of 12 in the trade value of everyone past your starters and flex — the bench you would trade from, not the bench you would start. Your lineup itself ranks 12th of 12 in weekly points.
−42%10thBench depth check
Can your bench survive an injury or a bye week?
0Coveredsurvives an injury1Thinone injury from trouble5Exposeda bye costs you a week
QB
QB depth5of 12teams pass
No startable backup
Jalen Milroe0.0 PPGneeds 14.1QB
RB
RB depth1of 12teams pass
No true RB injury cover
Keaton Mitchell5.9 PPGneeds 9RB
WR
WR depth6of 12teams pass
Receiver bench is too thin
DeMario Douglas6.5 PPGneeds 9WR
TE
TE depth9of 12teams pass
No usable TE2
Kenyon Sadiq5.9 PPGneeds 6TE
FLEX
Flex depth6of 12teams pass
Bench flex is a weekly risk
DeMario Douglas6.5 PPGneeds 9WR
2ND FLEX
2nd flex4of 12teams pass
Second backup slot is fragile
DeMario Douglas6.5 PPGneeds 9WR
Roster diagnosis
Holding you back
3 problems
- 1DEPTHYour bench is short in 5 spotsYou start 2 quarterbacks and nobody behind them clears 14.1 PPG. In superflex that is the fastest way to lose a week. No back behind your starters clears 9 PPG. One injury and you are starting a handcuff. No receiver behind your starters clears 9 PPG. Most rosters carry one, and bye weeks punish you without it. Nobody behind your starting tight end clears 6 PPG. Not hard to fix, but you need one. Nothing on your bench clears 9 PPG. Bye weeks will cost you.
- 2WRWR is a hole, not a position group−57%Your receiver room holds −57% of the trade value the average team carries there and ranks 12th of 12. Every week you start someone the rest of the league would bench.
- 3RBRB is a hole, not a position group−32%Your running back room holds −32% of the trade value the average team carries there and ranks 7th of 12. There is no week where this group wins you the matchup.
Your edge
2 advantages
- 1TETE is your strongest room+57%Your tight end room holds +57% of what the average team carries there and ranks 4th of 12 — but you start 2 tight ends a week once flex slots are filled and only 2 of them clear 6 PPG, so none of it is spare. The move here is trading quality down at TE and taking a startable body back, not shipping a TE out for nothing.
- 2You already own 5 TFR buysTyler Warren, Kenyon Sadiq, Jahan Dotson are flagged BUY on our board. The market has not caught up to these yet — hold them.
Trading difficultyHow easily this roster can make a deal. All your value in three studs scores low, because any trade opens a hole in your lineup. Value spread across seven or eight useful players — and picks in the first two rounds — scores high: you can make a real offer without gutting yourself.
How easy it is for you to make a deal
6.3/ 10
0–4.5Hard4.5–7Moderate7–9Easy9–10Very easy
5Top-90 players
Below avgLeague avg 7.5
81st & 2nd picks
Above avgLeague avg 4.0
43%Value in top 3
Spread outLeague avg 49%
2Movable bench
Above avgLeague avg 0.8
The verdict
Trading from this roster is moderate.
- Mid-sized deals work without touching the lineup
- Your picks can pay for an upgrade
- No single trade guts this roster
Trade Ideas
These are alternative deals, not a sequence — you would do one of them, which is why the same piece can appear on more than one card. They come in four kinds. FILLS A NEED moves value from a room you're long in to the one you're short in. TIER UP sends one of your starters plus a piece for a better player at the same position — for the rooms that are already fine but could be better. YOUR BOARD comes from the Buy/Hold/Sell board: a player you're selling moved while someone will still pay, or a player you're buying asked for by name. SELL THE VET and WIN-NOW BUY are the trades where the two plans meet — a rebuild selling a veteran to a contender for youth or picks, or a contender paying a rebuild in futures for a producer. Every offer is checked for whether a person would accept it, not just whether the values add up: the side getting the best player pays a premium for consolidating, you can't buy someone far above the best chip you own, and every player you send has to be someone who'd actually crack their lineup. A rebuild is never handed back an older player than it sends, and a contender is never handed a player who is out for the season. The percentage on each card is whether that manager would actually want it — their window, whether it lands in a room they are thin at, what it costs them, and how often they trade at all.alternatives — you'd do one of them8.5Trade market: Very active13 completed trades since July — about 2.2 per team. Managers here deal, so an aggressive offer will get a real look.
BetaTrade ideas are in beta and can be wrong — use them as a starting point, not as advice to follow blindly. Found a bad one? Screenshot it and send it to matthewbarghout on Discord — every real example is how we fix the logic.
SELL THE VETanunno16trades occasionally
anunno16 is contending and you are not. TreVeyon Henderson is 24 — he is worth more to a title run this season than to your roster in two, so sell him to the team that needs him now and take back draft capital.
- TreVeyon Henderson is on your SELL board — your read: “Price dropping… explosive, but also Rhamondre under contract for 3 years….”
⇄They receive
TreVeyon HendersonRB
You receive
2028 1stPick
Fair offerA straight swap at the same tier, priced at the going rate — the easiest kind of offer to get a yes on.A one-for-one at the same tier — the easiest kind of deal to get answered, and the shape the market prices most reliably. Offers are built smallest-first, and every player going out has to be someone who would actually crack their lineup — filler they'd bench is what makes a trade offer get ignored.
62% likelyWorth sending: they are contending and this sends them bodies rather than futures.
What Changes Your Window?
The gap between where you are and the next window, sized in the thing that actually moves it — points of starting-lineup production, or the value you'd need to add.At 84% this is not a close call, and the 39.9 PPG between you and a top-third lineup is too wide to buy in one offseason. What moves you to RELOAD is turning your oldest starters into young receivers and picks — and then not spending them.
Draft capitalEvery future pick you hold. A pick is priced as the player it is expected to become, so where it lands in the round is most of what it is worth — and where it lands is set by how the roster that owes it is projected to finish, not by how good they look on paper. You project to finish 12th of 12, so your own picks land early in each round.
12 picks over the next 2 drafts — about 2.3× what an average roster holds.
#1 / 12
Pick value rankEvery pick added up at this league's prices, ranked against the other 11 rosters.
12
Total picks
2.3×
League averageYour picks' combined value against what an average roster in this league holds. 1.0× is exactly average.
2027 draft7 picksProjected order
1.011st roundearly2027 1st · 1.01Worth about the dynasty #33 player.
1.101st roundlateAcquired2027 1st (duesybag) · 1.10Worth about the dynasty #76 player. From duesybag, who project to finish 3rd of 12 — a late one.
2.012nd roundearly2027 2nd · 2.01Worth about the dynasty #129 player.
2.042nd roundearlyAcquired2027 2nd (Venezia FC) · 2.04Worth about the dynasty #141 player. From Venezia FC, who project to finish 9th of 12 — an early pick in the round.
2.062nd roundmidAcquired2027 2nd (The Love Train) · 2.06Worth about the dynasty #149 player. From The Love Train, who project to finish 7th of 12 — the middle of the round.
3.013rd roundearly2027 3rd · 3.01Worth about the dynasty #205 player.
4.014th roundearly2027 4th · 4.01Worth about the dynasty #259 player.
2028 draft5 picksMid-round estimate
1.041st round~mid2028 1st · 1.04Worth about the dynasty #55 player. Two drafts out, so it is priced near the middle of the round — nobody's finish can be called that far ahead.
1.081st round~midAcquired2028 1st (Kirko Chain Smokers) · 1.08Worth about the dynasty #72 player. From Kirko Chain Smokers. Two drafts out, so it is priced near the middle of the round — nobody's finish can be called that far ahead.
2.042nd round~mid2028 2nd · 2.04Worth about the dynasty #148 player. Two drafts out, so it is priced near the middle of the round — nobody's finish can be called that far ahead.
3.043rd round~mid2028 3rd · 3.04Worth about the dynasty #221 player. Two drafts out, so it is priced near the middle of the round — nobody's finish can be called that far ahead.
4.044th round~mid2028 4th · 4.04Worth about the dynasty #274 player. Two drafts out, so it is priced near the middle of the round — nobody's finish can be called that far ahead.
Draft capital value
#1of 12
Your pick value ranks 1st in this league.
Picks by year
20277
20285
Top asset
1.01Your most valuable pick.
2027 1st roundearly
Worth about the dynasty #33 player.
Sign in to see this
Free account — takes 30 seconds. Rankings stay open to everyone.
Create free accountAlready have one? Sign in
Browse the rankings